Yes/No/Irrelevant Guess the Whole Story Game - Story 1

[malex]

Ok I see you enjoy riddle/story games, so Ill jump with this kind of game:
The rules are simple: You can ask any question to which I can only answer with: Yes, No or IRRELEVANT

So the story I'm about to tell you is incomplete (as in I've skipped a part of the actions happened). You must find out the whole story.

Here's the story:
A man enters a bar. He asks for a glass of water. The barman pulls out his gun and threatens the man. The man says thank you and leaves.

Rules:
- Just make sure the question can be answered with one of the three responses.
- You can ask as many questions you want, just make sure they weren't answered already.

Dr. brad got it:

The man has hiccups. He asks for the water to stop his hiccups. However, the bartender has a better cure --> a gun = fear & surprise --> goodbye hiccups

[Poppy]

Was the man thirsty when he entered the bar?

[malex]

Was the man thirsty when he entered the bar?

No

[Lady in Ice]

was there a fire somewhere?

[Shortstuff]

Was the barman having an affair with the mans wife?

[Dr Brad]

Did the man have hiccups?

[malex]

was there a fire somewhere?

Irrelevant

Was the barman having an affair with the mans wife?

No

Did the man have hiccups?

(did you knew it?) ... Thats it..

[Joedakiller]

Was the man a criminal?

[Dr Brad]

The man has hiccups. He asks for the water to stop his hiccups. However, the bartender has a better cure --> a gun = fear & surprise --> goodbye hiccups

[malex]

Gratz Dr. Brad, you got it right

Will come back with a new story